Support Local Journalism!      

Link to Owner Dr. Robert B. Pamplin Jr.



Labor-backed initiative to cap grocery store self-checkout stands to two per store a step closer to the ballot.

COURTESY PHOTO: DREAMSTIME - Grocery stores could be forced to limit the number of self-checkout lines under a new initiative trying to make its way to the ballot.Are grocery store self-checkout lanes an annoyance? A convenience? Do they reduce the number of grocery store jobs?

A federation of Oregon workers wants voters to issue a verdict on the self-checkout kiosks becoming more prevalent at grocery stores.

A petition to limit each grocery store to two of the checkout kiosks can soon move forward to signature gathering. On Friday, Jan. 24, the Oregon Supreme Court certified the attorney general's description of the proposed measure. Sandra McDonough, Oregon Business & Industry president and chief executive officer, challenged Attorney General Ellen Rosenblum's description of the proposed measure, asking the Supreme Court to review it.

Backers need 112,020 signatures to get to voters' ballots in November.

PMG/EO MEDIA/SRFiled in July by former Oregon AFL-CIO President Tom Chamberlain of Portland, Initiative Petition 41 is backed by a coalition of labor groups representing about 300,000 Oregon workers.

"We have been consistently concerned about the impacts of technology and automation on the livelihoods of working people, especially when they have no voice in how technology is used in their workplaces," said Graham Trainor, president of the Oregon AFL-CIO, in a statement. "You can see expansion of self-checkout machines in stores across the country and in Oregon."

He said jobs were lost as a result.

The AFL-CIO contends self-checkout kiosks make customers feel socially isolated, particularly elderly people, and that the kiosks let stores rely more on part-time workers and leaves workers "feeling devalued." They also claim that self-checkout stands make it easier for minors to buy alcohol and for people to steal from stores.

Measure is 'tone deaf'

Joe Gilliam, president of the Northwest Grocery Association, an industry group, scoffed at the labor group's claims, calling the proposed measure "a bit perplexing and very misguided."

PMG FILE PHOTO - An initiative to limit self-checkout stations in grocery stores got the OK to gather signatures to put it on a ballot.

"Today's customer wants convenience and less hassle when shopping," Gilliam wrote in an email to the Oregon Capital Bureau. "This is evident in the growth of online shopping for local pick-up and home delivery. This measure is tone deaf to what the public is demanding in the marketplace."

He said that self-checkout lets customers check out more quickly and privately. He said presuming that self-checkout machines would replace workers is "simply untrue."

"Employees are our lifeblood and provide key services that no machine can duplicate," Gilliam said.

The measure would give the state Bureau of Labor and Industries enforcement power and let it issue penalties for stores that provide too many self-service stations.

In court documents, McDonough argued the proposed restriction would have a "substantial impact" on retailers and shoppers. She argued that the ballot title wasn't clear that "virtually all Oregonians" could sue grocery stores that have more than two self-checkout kiosks.

"Today's customer wants convenience and less hassle when shopping."

PMG FILE PHOTO - Oregon's Supreme Court has cleared the way for a labor-backed initiative to limit self-checkout stations in grocery stores."The ballot title process, which we were just in, is about making sure, if the measure actually gets on the ballot, that the words that describe it accurately reflect what the measure's going to do," said McDonough in an interview. "… And we're going to wait to see if it makes it on ballot. And if it does, then we'll assess what we're going to do about it. But from our perspective, this is really about what consumers want."

Evan Christopher, a lawyer for Gilliam, echoed similar concerns about potential lawsuits in a letter to the secretary of state's elections division last fall. "Voters must be informed that (the initiative petition) permits every employee who complains about a self-checkout and is later terminated or demoted or given a different work schedule to call his or her employer into court on a claim of retaliation," Christopher wrote. "Every customer who files a complaint about a self-checkout machine and is later asked to leave the same store — for whatever reason — would have the same claim."

Reporter Claire Withycombe: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. or 971-304-4148.

You count on us to stay informed and we depend on you to fund our efforts. Quality local journalism takes time and money. Please support us to protect the future of community journalism.

Have a thought or opinion on the news of the day? Get on your soapbox and share your opinions with the world. Send us a Letter to the Editor!

Go to top
JSN Time 2 is designed by | powered by JSN Sun Framework