Unions say equipment shortages, technological constraints are limiting state workers' ability to work remotely

PMG FILE PHOTO - Oregon Gov. Kate Brown has urged all employers to allow as many workers as possible to do their jobs from home. State employees are finding this to be a challenge.Across Oregon, schools and restaurants are shuttered, employers are encouraged to allow telecommuting and people are being told they should just stay home as the state tries to slow down a deadly surge of the novel coronavirus.

But getting state government, which employs about 40,483 people, to follow Gov. Kate Brown's lead hasn't been as straightforward.

State agencies have taken steps to allow employees to work remotely or to stay home to prevent spreading the virus. But such arrangements encountered technological constraints and a public that is increasingly calling on state government for help with health care or economic insecurity.

In response to the outbreak, the state Department of Administrative Services signed agreements last week with the two large state employee unions.

The agreements, which last through June, expand leave options and specify that employee requests to telecommute "will be presumed to be acceptable." But the work-at-home requests can be denied if there is a lack of laptops, cell phone or network availability. Nearly half of state jobs are located in Salem.

David Kreisman, communications director for Oregon AFSCME Council 75, said that while the agreement has helped, issues remain.

"The biggest issue with the (agreement) and telecommuting is there is not enough technology and laptops to do this work," he said.

He said that the union, which represents about 4,000 employees, has heard of state workers being denied telecommuting requests because of a lack of laptops.

Protective gear scarce

Kreisman pointed out that the state also has a shortage of masks and other protective equipment to keep workers from contracting the virus. He said he heard a report of behavioral health workers using bandanas instead of medical masks when working with clients who tested positive for the coronavirus.

PMG FILE PHOTO - Repreresentatives for Oregon public employee unions say their members, like workers across the state, are running low on equipment designed to keep them safe.Kreisman said that to keep workers and the public safe, it's time for the governor to mandate shelter-in-place, a drastic measure that would shutter non-essential businesses and government services. He said that demand for some government services is already diminishing.

"Nobody is going to get a building permit. Nobody needs to take a driving test," he said.

Liz Merah, a spokeswoman for both the governor's office and the Department of Administrative Services, said in an email that there were no plans to lay off any state employees because of the outbreak.

So far, the Department of Environmental Quality, the Oregon Lottery and Oregon Driver and Motor Vehicle Services have curtailed operations and services in response to the outbreak.

Melissa Unger, executive director for SEIU 503, said her union isn't calling for a shelter-in-place order and is working with each agency to balance protections for state workers while also making sure that government agencies are carrying out services at a time when they're especially needed.

She said that her union represents the largest share of government workers, about 23,000. Those include employees who have regular contact with other people at the Employment Department, the Department of Human Services, the Oregon State Hospital and the Oregon Youth Authority.

"It's challenging because of all the needs," she said. "And, to be honest, we are on the front line of those needs."

Many state functions are vital

Unger said that other state functions that may not seem obviously essential need to continue amid the outbreak. She said one example is the workforce needed for state tax services to send rebates to a cash-strapped public.

She said that a barrier to telecommuting is that the aging technology used by state government can't be easily transferred to a laptop. She also said that the shortage of masks and protective equipment is an issue for her union.

Calls for comment Friday to the representatives of Human Services and Transportation departments weren't returned.

Jennifer Kalez, communications director for the Department of Energy, said in an email that the department remains open and is following social distancing guidelines. She said that about a third of the department's 72 employees are teleworking full time and others are doing so more sporadically.

Merah said that there wasn't a figure for how many state employees are telecommuting because it isn't centrally managed. But she said that about one-third of the 333 full-time employees in the Department of Administrative Services are telecommuting.

She also wasn't aware of issues with laptops because each agency manages its own IT hardware.

"However, we do know that many agencies are moving more and more in the direction of allowing telework for employees," said Merah.

She said that the state is negotiating similar agreements with the rest of the state's labor organizations, of which there are nine.

Jake Thomas is a reporter for the Oregon Capital Bureau. Contact him at 503-575-1251 or This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. or @jakethomas2009.

You count on us to stay informed and we depend on you to fund our efforts. Quality local journalism takes time and money. Please support us to protect the future of community journalism.