Support Local Journalism!        

Link to Owner Dr. Robert B. Pamplin Jr.



Oregon Supreme Court hears arguments from state, plaintiffs on Chernaik v. Brown at David Douglas High on Nov. 13

PMG PHOTO: ZANE SPARLING - The Oregon Supreme Court listens to arguments from counsel for the plaintiff Courtney Johnson at the David Douglas auditorium on Nov. 13.The Oregon Supreme Court made a road trip to east Portland, offering students a firsthand look at an ongoing lawsuit — filed by fellow kids — that could require Oregon to more forcefully fight climate change.

More than 400 students packed the David Douglas High School auditorium on Wednesday, Nov. 13, with some traveling from West Linn and Catlin Gabel, in order to hear oral arguments in Chernaik v. Brown.

The suit, first filed in 2011, argues that Oregon has a responsibility to spend money to protect the atmosphere and other natural resources from the effects of rising temperatures as a provision of the Public Trust doctrine, which typically is applied only to rivers.

"The record is undisputed that climate change is already impacting the navigable waterways of the state," said counsel for the plaintiff Courtney Johnson.

PMG PHOTO: ZANE SPARLING - Chernaik v. Brown is based on the ancient Public Trust doctrine, which was established during the Byzantine Empire. The suit targets Gov. Kate Brown, who along with other Democrats made an ultimately unsuccessful effort to pass cap-and-trade legislation in the statehouse earlier this year. Her lawyer argued that judicial fiat is an inappropriate way to cut carbon dioxide emissions.

"The way that the state does more to combat climate change is by passing laws," said Brown's counsel, Carson Whitehead. Otherwise, "it's encroachment."

Judges in Lane County and at the State Appeals Court have sided with Gov. Brown and rejected the suit's argument on multiple occasions, leading to several appeals and the Oregon Supreme Court's voluntary decision to hear the case.

The seven judges on stage made no decision, but pushed back on both lawyers' half-hour-long arguments, asking what would be an appropriate decision for the court if the Willamette River were, hypothetically, suddenly blocked by a natural disaster or human-made wall.

Johnson said it would be an impetus to act: "When the state is abdicating its role here, that is the same as causing substantial impairment."

PMG PHOTO: ZANE SPARLING - More than 400 students from David Douglas High School, West Linn and Caitlin Gabel School attended a recent traveling session of the Oregon Supreme Court. Whitehead again called for an electoral solution, though he admitted to the gravity of the situation. "Climate change is a huge problem," he said, "in no small part because our economy has been carbon based for a long, long time, and it remains so."

Though the day lacked the booming oratory of legal dramas — and incongruous congas remained firmly planted in the orchestra pit — many students were clearly enthralled.

Mock Trial participant and David Douglas senior Annabelle Sukin praised the learning experience, noting how the judges' questioning pushed the lawyers to explain their rhetoric.

"Justice and equality throughout argument are really important," Sukin said. "Socratic arguments and philosophical debates are more prominent in my classrooms, especially here at Douglas."

Visitors to the school campus were greeted by environmental activists holding a silent vigil supporting the lawsuit. One of the protesters, Gary Houser, explained their mission: "We feel climate disruption is an extremely serious threat to the future of life on this planet." PMG PHOTO: ZANE SPARLING - Protesters with Extinction Rebellion and other groups held a silent prayer vigil outside the David Douglas parking lot before the Oregon Supreme Court arrived.

You count on us to stay informed and we depend on you to fund our efforts. Quality local journalism takes time and money. Please support us to protect the future of community journalism.

Have a thought or opinion on the news of the day? Get on your soapbox and share your opinions with the world. Send us a Letter to the Editor!


- Middle schooler uses science experiments to solve global crises

- Does climate change threaten the Oregon wine industry?

- Youth can lead climate future, but politicians must listen

- Bonamici: House focused on issues other than impeachment

- Wyden fields questions from students at Westview High School

- Fight climate crisis with range of renewables

Go to top
JSN Time 2 is designed by | powered by JSN Sun Framework