Senate passes Measure 11 reform on slimmest of margins
Juveniles charged with violent crimes could get a second chance to avoid treatment as adults under a reform to Measure 11 passed by the Senate Tuesday, April 16, on the slimmest of margins.
If Senate Bill 1008 were to win two-thirds support in the House, as it did in the Senate, it would allow more flexibility in dealing with juvenile offenders. The policy allows a judge to decide whether teens 15 to 18 could be charged as an adult for a violent crime. Prosecutors now make that decision.
The reform also would allow a juvenile the chance to convince a judge they have been rehabilitated and shouldn't be transferred to adult prison to finish their sentence. That would align the state with a U.S. Supreme Court decision finding juveniles should not be sentenced to life without parole. Research shows teenagers' brains are still developing, especially parts that control impulse, Floyd Prozanski, D-Eugene, said on the Senate floor before the vote.
In 1994, Oregon voters passed Measure 11, a stringent mandatory minimum sentencing law for violent offenders. The law took a significant amount of discretion from judges and put it in the hands of prosecutors, who decide whether to charge someone under Measure 11. In addition to getting longer mandatory sentences, those convicted under Measure 11 aren't eligible for early release.
To date, 1,207 juveniles have been sentenced under Measure 11, according to Department of Corrections data. As of April 1, 272 were in Oregon Department of Corrections custody and 122 were in Oregon Youth Authority custody.
The legislation was carried by Senators Jackie Winters, R-Salem, and Prozanski more than 24 years after Measure 11 passed. Winters said on the Senate floor that she has championed juvenile justice reform for 50 years. Winters' late husband was convicted as a teenager and spent time in an adult prison. Winters said her husband told her prison was no place for a juvenile.
"You are teaching the individual, especially the juveniles, how to be better criminals," Winters said. A teenager sentenced under Measure 11 goes into the custody of Oregon Youth Authority, but can later be transferred to an adult prison.
Prozanski said the state spends three times more on a juvenile in Oregon Youth Authority custody than on someone in an adult person. That's because the focus is on reform. But once they enter prison, the focus for the offender becomes surviving.
"All of that investment goes away," he said.
Sen. Dennis Linthicum, R-Klamath Falls, said the spike in imprisonment in the 1980s wasn't because people suddenly became worse people. It was the result of bad policy that didn't focus on transitioning people out of the prison system, he said. "We know how to tail them, nail them and jail them," Linthicum said. "We don't know how to exhale them."
As the Senate voted, one Republican, Sen. Dallas Heard, R-Roseburg, sidestepped the vote when first called on. He sat with his head in his hands as the rest of the senators cast votes.
Winters and Linthicum were the only Republicans to vote in favor and one Democrat, Sen. Betsy Johnson, opposed it.
The vote stood at 19-10. A reform of a voter-approved measure required two-thirds of the senators to support it. The fate of the bill came down to one vote: Heard's. He joined Winters and Linthicum in voting for the bill, passing it out of the Senate and sending it on to the House.
Heard declined comment after the vote.
A second chance
For decades, lawmakers have shown little appetite to reform the policy, despite states throughout the country repealing similar laws. That was in part due to the powerful Oregon District Attorneys Association, which opposed SB 1008. According to Prozanski, there was strong support, including from the Oregon Youth Authority and Department of Corrections.
Senate President Peter Courtney said politics also has hindered reform.
"One of the most deadly things to use … is this kind of stuff in a campaign — that they're weak on law and order, that they're releasing criminals," Courtney said after the vote. "The politics of this is fierce."
For Courtney, the bill was personal. Growing up, he said on the Senate floor, he got in violent fistfights that could've made him a Measure 11 offender. He said when he looks at the people in prison, he can see himself. The difference, he said, is someone came into his life and turned him around as he was about to be kicked out of school.
"Peter, I have not given up on you, but boy do I expect more," he recalled that person say saying.
It allowed him a second chance. That's what he wants to give the teens of his district.
"They had two strikes against them through no fault of their own," Courtney said of those in Oregon Youth Authority custody. "Talk about three strikes and you're out."
Courtney said reforms are suddenly possible because of a changing tide in public opinion about the criminal justice system.
He hopes the success from Tuesday would be followed by legislation that would disallow split juries to convict defendants. Oregon is the only state that doesn't require a unanimous vote by jurors.
Quality local journalism takes time and money, which comes, in part, from paying readers. If you enjoy articles like this one, please consider supporting us.
(It costs just a few cents a day.)