Republican legislators on Tuesday, Feb. 18, put the brakes on the Legislature, disrupting a House evening session by leaving in protest because they said their members needed more time to consider contentious bills.
The House needs two-thirds of its 60 members to take votes. That means at least two Republicans must show up with Democrats to have a legal quorum. Just one — Rep. Cheri Helt, R-Bend — showed up for Tuesday evening's session.
Starting at 6 p.m., House Democrats milled about and chatted while waiting for other lawmakers to show. They formed occasional huddles. Rep. David Gomberg, D-Otis, at one point could be heard plunking out notes on a piano that's on the House floor for musical performances.
An hour in, when it was clear that there would not be enough lawmakers for a quorum, House Speaker Tina Kotek, D-Portland, issued retribution by gavel: she discharged Rep. Greg Smith, R-Heppner, from chairing a budget sub-committee, assigning Democrat Pam Marsh of Ashland, in his stead.
"Being a chair comes with an extra set of responsibilities and expectations," Kotek said in a statement. "Not only did Rep. Smith not come to work tonight, he didn't submit an excuse for his absence."
After adjournment, House Democratic Leader Barbara Smith Warner of Portland, described Republicans' absence as "the politics of obstruction."
"Those members who refuse to show up for work tonight and do their job are saying to a large majority of Oregonians: your voice doesn't matter and your vote doesn't matter," Smith Warner said in a statement. "Oregonians deserve much better."
Rep. Barbara Smith Warner
Capitol Phone: 503-986-1445
Capitol Address: 900 Court St NE, H-295, Salem, OR 97301
A slower pace
Tuesday afternoon, House Republican Leader Christine Drazan, who took over the 22-member caucus in September, was opaque about the idea that Republicans are denying a quorum. "We need to take time to look at these issues and give them our full consideration," Drazan said. "So it's not about denying quorum, but it absolutely is about setting a pace inside the building that allows for us to give all of these really big ideas in the short session their due."
Representative Christine Drazan
Capitol Phone: 503-986-1439
Capitol Address: 900 Court St NE, H-395, Salem, OR 97301
Drazan's announcement came a day after Kotek said Monday, Feb. 17, that the House would be holding more hearings, in response to Republicans' concerns, on a much-discussed proposal to cap the state's greenhouse gas emissions. The proposal, known as cap and trade, is the main course on the political menu this session, and it's an issue that riles many Republicans — and moderate Democrats.
In a written statement Tuesday, Kotek said Drazan notified her of the Republican caucus' intention to not attend this evening's session. But Kotek pointed out that she has obliged Republican insistence that each bill be read in its entirety, a tedious process that by late Tuesday afternoon had consumed nearly four hours of a House session.
Kotek said that was one reason she had scheduled an evening floor session for Tuesday.
"Our deadlines require that we move bills that have passed out of policy committees off the House floor by Thursday," Kotek said. "If the House Republican Caucus wants to continue reading bills tonight, that alone will require nearly three hours on the floor."
Rep. Tina Kotek
Capitol Phone: 503-986-1200
Capitol Address: 900 Court St NE, 269, Salem, OR 97301
Republicans in the House have refused to suspend rules that require clerks to read the bills aloud line by line. It's a tactic the minority party can use to slow down the legislative process.
Drazan addressed the reason for that tactic in a news conference Tuesday afternoon.
"I'm not looking to save time," Drazan said. "I'm not looking to consolidate anything. I'm looking to set a pace that is a pace that allows for engagement. And so reading bills helps set a slower pace."
Kotek noted legislation scheduled to be considered Tuesday evening had bipartisan support, including a 53-page bill that adopting the federal Indian Child Welfare Act into state law.
Helt, the lone Republican on the floor Tuesday night, declined an interview request after the floor session, but issued a statement: "My attendance tonight was my way of protesting the failure of the majority party to respect the legitimate concerns of my Republican colleagues," Helt said. "I hope tomorrow we will work together with greater respect for the legislative process and respecting opposing points of view."
'It's about money'
The increasingly tense political machinations under the Capitol dome hold the prospect of gumming up the works as lawmakers approach the halfway point of the 35-day session, and as Senate Republicans grow closer to repeating their 2019 performance: two "walkouts" that ultimately killed three policies they opposed.
Staying away from the evening session was intended, Drazan said, to "provide more space and more opportunity for our members to digest the amendments that are coming through committees, to make sure that between all of the scheduled consideration of legislation to really allow for thorough vetting of these ideas."
"We will be there bright and early tomorrow, you know, smile on our face, ready to get back to work."
By contrast, Sen. Herman Baertschiger Jr., who leads the minority Republicans in the Senate, has issued regular confrontational statements aimed at Democrats. On Monday, it was an exhortation to Senate President Peter Courtney to work on the state budget before taking on more controversial priorities. On Tuesday, he railed against what he called a "deception" by Gov. Kate Brown for supporting the removal of four dams on the Snake River.
"If cap-and-trade were really about reducing carbon emissions, the governor would not be taking an opposing position to that goal by seeking to get rid of four of the Snake River dams, which provide sustainable energy for Oregonians and reduce carbon," Baertschiger said in a statement. "Cap-and-trade is not about the environment. It's about money."
Oregon Capital Bureau reporters Claire Withycombe, Jake Thomas and Sam Stites contributed to this news story.
You count on us to stay informed and we depend on you to fund our efforts. Quality local journalism takes time and money. Please support us to protect the future of community journalism.