Link to Owner Dr. Robert B. Pamplin Jr.



The real culprit might be the location of the Mark O. Hatfield Federal Courthouse next to the Justice Center in downtown Portland.

PMG FILE PHOTO - A scene of a protest in downtown Portland.Within the chaos of Tuesday's presidential debate between President Donald Trump and Democratic contender Joe Biden, Portland was repeatedly mentioned, mostly referring to recent protests. But just how did the Rose City of all topics get entangled into a main focal point of a national discussion?

KOIN 6 News reached out to experts in political science and social movements from Portland State University to get their perspectives on the debate, which was marred with frequent interruptions from the president and exchanges of name-calling in what was a contentious and messy affair.

Chris Shortell is an Associate Professor of Political Science at PSU. He told KOIN 6 News the attention Portland is getting may be a "kind of quirk of luck, or bad luck, depending on how you want to characterize that."

Part of the reason for the spotlight on Portland may be because of the protests which spanned over 100 days consecutively this past summer, he said. Though Black Lives Matter protests have also swept other areas of the country, other cities may not have been as consistently frequent.

However, it's the happenstance of where many of the protests were held that may be the real culprit: the location of the Mark O. Hatfield Federal Courthouse downtown.

"That might sound like an odd reason, but because the federal courthouse is right next door to the Justice Center in downtown Portland, it meant that while protests were happening and were primarily targeting the Justice Center, the U.S. Marshal's Service and other federal law enforcement tasked with protecting the federal courthouse got involved in how to deal with and address those protests," Shortell explained.

There was an opportunity in that scenario for federal law enforcement to increase their role and visibility, he said.

"Once that happened, it really increased the visibility of Portland on the national stage because we became the sort of test for how federal law enforcement might happen with regard to the protests," Shortell said.

Portland's role in the national debate did not come as a surprise to Shirley A. Jackson, a sociologist and Black Studies Professor at PSU.

"As somebody who studies social movements, this was so obviously going to be on the agenda," she said.

Jackson said the use of Portland as a talking point was brought up by Trump to put a wedge between protesters and the authorities.

"That wedge that was driven … was also in large part aided by the introduction of federal authorities into Portland to quell the uprising that was happening this past summer," she said.

Jackson said cities like Portland should be concerned about the intense level of federal intervention they may face with Trump in the White House.

"There are certain cities that have a target on their backs," she said.

Jackson lamented the direction of the protests sidelining the Black Lives Matter movement and legitimate calls for justice, which she feels should remain center stage.

"What was unfortunate was that Black Lives Matter protests, in Portland in particular, started to become equated with antifa," she said. "[Trump] would like to label antifa as a terrorist group. Once you make that link between antifa and Black Lives Matter, it becomes really hard to separate those two in some people's minds."

During the debate, President Trump danced around a question from moderator Chris Wallance about whether he was willing to condemn white supremacists and paramilitary groups. Instead Trump said of the far-right group Proud Boys, which is considered a hate group by the Anti-Defamation League, to "stand back and stand by," adding "somebody's got to do something about antifa and the left because this is not a right-wing problem ... This is a left-wing problem."

That message was even adopted by some members of Proud Boys as a slogan, though Amazon has since announced it would be removing T-shirts with the words "stand back, stand by" sold on its site. Additionally, Proud Boys' president, Enrique Tarrio, said he did not interpret the president's words as an endorsement of the group.

Shortell and Jackson said they found Trump's remark, and lack of condemning white supremacy violence, to be deeply troubling and problematic, respectively.

"To see these sorts of comments come out of the mouth of Trump, really deeply divisive, it clearly shows the agenda that this particular person has," Jackson said. "And it has further divided a country that really needs to be in a state of healing after everything we've gone through this past year."

"That kind of rhetoric is something that can lead to greater violence," Shortell added.

The day after the debate, Trump tried to walk back his refusal to outright condemn violence of white supremacist groups. He said he didn't know who the Proud Boys are and that "whoever they are they have to stand down, let law enforcement do their work."

During the debate, President Trump also said he received the endorsement of the "Portland Sheriff." Though Portland does not have a sheriff, Multnomah County Sheriff Mike Reese tweeted the night of the debate that he does not and "will never support him."

KOIN News 6 is a news partner of the Portland Tribune. Their story can be found here.

You count on us to stay informed and we depend on you to fund our efforts. Quality local journalism takes time and money. Please support us to protect the future of community journalism.

Go to top
JSN Time 2 is designed by | powered by JSN Sun Framework