Portland mayor to halt funding for Hazelnut Grove homeless
UPDATE: Portland Mayor Ted Wheeler will continue funding Hazelnut Grove for six months, per Commissioner Dan Ryan. But Wheeler's staff contradicted Ryan, saying there is no "firm timeline" for such an extension. Confused? So are we. Either way, find the latest news here and read our exclusive report that brought the situation to light below:
Portland Mayor Ted Wheeler plans to chop off roughly $1,500 in monthly funding to Hazelnut Grove Village. And officials are moving forward with relocation plans some residents have vowed to resist.
Rather than charging in with bulldozers — and risking a full-throated eviction defense — Wheeler's strategy could leave the long-running but never officially permitted tiny house community to wither on the vine.
Or maybe not. Employees under Wheeler's sway have suggested their own novel solution: Let Commissioner Jo Ann Hardesty pay for it.
"(Portland Bureau of Transportation) actually owns that property," said city spokeswoman Heather Hafer. "If PBOT and Commissioner Hardesty want to continue that funding, that's going to be up to them, but we're basically going to transfer that over."
PBOT: What funding?
Hardesty is indeed at the helm of the city's Transportation Bureau under the city's archaic commission form of government, and has shown support for the village on social media. But the bureau already is preparing to tighten its belt due to plummeting gas tax and parking meter revenue, its only sources of discretionary funding. By law, gas tax money must be spent on road projects.
The proposal to pick up the tab caught PBOT staff off guard.
"Continue what funding? How much?" asked one surprised PBOT spokesman.
As confusion reigns at City Hall, Commissioner Dan Ryan has been quietly meeting with Hazelnut Grove residents, leaving them with the impression the camp's closure has been delayed. But Ryan didn't mention any end to funding, which pays for portable bathrooms, trash collection and a fence.
"Implicit in saying that the plan for demolishing is suspended is saying that the services are continuing," said activist and Hazelnut supporter Peggy Zebroski, who joined a video conference call with Ryan. She said the village will build its own fencing and composting toilets, if need be.
"I'm highly suspicious and concerned, and we will continue to make maximal efforts on every front we can," Zebroski said, "down to asking the community to do a peaceful defense if it comes to that."
Staff for the mayor's bureaus said funding will cease only after the opening of St. Johns Village, a nonprofit-operated housing pod community officials say has room for everyone living at Hazelnut Grove.
The doors in St. Johns are supposed to swing open in the first week of March or the beginning of the second week, according to the Joint Office of Homeless Services. But whether that date will stick is unclear, as several previously slated openings were delayed by the winter weather and problems relating to construction of the project's modular common building that will be connected to utilities.
"Mayor Wheeler believes we must move with urgency to create more and better safe shelter options for people experiencing homelessness," said mayoral spokesman Jim Middaugh. "This requires creativity, a willingness to try new things and the flexibility to learn and improve as we go."
The Homeless and Urban Camping Impact Reduction Program, controlled by the mayor, says crews will deconstruct individual tiny homes only after they have been vacated — with intentions to repurpose them at some other location eventually.
"However, once St. Johns Village is open, the mayor's bureaus will no longer pay for the amenities and services currently provided at Hazelnut Grove," said Hafer, spokeswoman for the Homelessness and Urban Camping Impact Reduction Program, sometimes called HUCIRP.
St. Johns Village was designed expressly to end the thorny question of Hazelnut Grove; whether folks will choose to leave voluntarily is another matter.
The Joint Office says Hazelnut Grove residents will fill eight of the 19 beds at St. Johns Village, while HUCIRP told the Tribune that 11 of the 15 people living at the Grove had agreed to move.
In response, Hazelnut resident Barbra Weber says "that is absolutely not true."
"There are five people moving to the village," Weber said. "And no one's moved yet."
Officials say St. Johns Village offers a low-barrier solution for those at Hazelnut Grove. Weber notes that the uniform, single-occupancy pods are a far cry from their meticulously handcrafted tiny homes, some of which have separate kitchens and porches, and are shared by married couples.
"I know people who desperately need services and want help, but I haven't needed that," Weber said. "I'm just not in support of forced services or background checks, or non-self-governing villages, just because that's not a right fit for me."
Grove's tangled saga
It's been nearly a month since City Hall officially announced plans on Jan. 18 to "decommission" the community, which sprang up on a wooded slope of city-own land in 2015.
The mayor's office began searching for an alternative site for the village in 2018, ultimately partnering with nonprofit service provider Do Good Multnomah and St. Johns Church, which loaned land for a new community in 2019.
While nearly 6,000 people have signed an online petition hoping to "save the village," officials have long cited the fire and landslide risk as reasons to uproot the village located between North Greeley and Interstate avenues.
The city purchased the land in 1956, a few years after constructing a 96-inch diameter sewer pipe 20 feet beneath the slope above the village, Bureau of Environmental Services Property Manager Eli Callison wrote in a city document.
"Staff likely (purchased the land) to protect the sewer infrastructure and adjacent roadway against landslides or other hillside failures that could occur if the property was developed," according to the memo dated Dec. 18. "With the steepness of this hillside (1:15), any changes to the current use of this property would require a geotech report and review."
Portland Fire & Rescue has provided fire extinguishers, smoke alarms and conducted safety inspections at Hazelnut Grove since 2017, and clears brush to create a 20-foot buffer around the village with cooperation from village leaders.
Even so, Fire Marshal A.J. Jackson noted the topography and seasonal dry winds create "the potential for significant fire hazards" on site in a separate memo on Jan. 6.
"While the current location of Hazelnut Grove is far from ideal, the community has been very responsive to the safety recommendations provided by our fire inspectors," Jackson wrote. "Should the village be relocated, our primary concern is that the area becomes occupied by a community that is far less amenable to our input."
Ryan promised reprieve
Whether the clock is about to run out on Hazelnut Grove — or headed into extra innings — depends on who you talk to.
In a closed-door meeting with Commissioner Ryan, the City Council's liaison with the Joint Office, multiple sources say Ryan indicated that the shutdown wasn't going to happen anytime soon.
"There was no definite plan to save the village, just that they weren't going to have our services cut off," Weber said of the meeting. "(Ryan) is going to have a hard time wiggling free from the promises he made, but I'm still a little concerned."
Commissioner Hardesty signaled her support for the cause on Feb. 9, writing on social media: "In my heart I know that however complicated the situation is, I am morally unsettled with forcibly moving people from their community at Hazelnut Grove."
The virtual meeting was held at noon on Thursday, Feb. 11, with several Overlook neighbors and organizers from Oregon's Poor People's Campaign, Sisters of the Road and Ecumenical Ministries on the call. Ryan was joined by his policy director, Mark Bond, and Chief of Staff Kellie Torres. Kaia Sand, executive director of Street Roots newspaper, served as moderator.
"The village has done no harm. It is an essential sanctuary for houseless people, and there is no reason to decommission it at all, and most certainly not in the depths of winter and during a COVID epidemic," said Zebroski, who lives in the neighborhood. "It's really important that the public hear that."
In a statement, Ryan's staff member Bond said the commissioner is seeking to expand alternative shelter capacity countywide.
"Commissioner Ryan believes that in this time of unprecedented crisis, we need to create as many options as possible to provide stability for our houseless neighbors," according to the statement. "Many in the community assume Commissioner Ryan has decision-making authority as it relates to Hazelnut Grove, which he does not."
The statement said Ryan was actively working to "facilitate increased communication" between Hardesty and Wheeler.
Follow me on Twitter
You count on us to stay informed and we depend on you to fund our efforts. Quality local journalism takes time and money. Please support us to protect the future of community journalism.