Scary forecast: Earthquake devastation will be far worse
The "Big One" will devastate Portland even more than scientists previously expected, according to a new state geologists' study of how a major earthquake will affect the tri-county area.
The study released Thursday, March 15, found that a magnitude 9 earthquake centered off the Oregon Coast in the Cascadia Subduction Zone would cause tens of thousands of casualties in the Portland area, displace tens of thousands of residents from their homes, and cost tens of billions of dollars in building damage.
In Portland alone, the study calculates 119 to 896 immediate deaths from a major Cascadia earthquake, depending on when it occurs, plus hundreds to thousands more life-threatening injuries and people requiring hospitalization.
Throughout Multnomah County, 302 to 677 buildings are projected to collapse.
"Although damage estimates vary widely throughout the study area, no community will be unharmed," concluded study authors John Bauer, William Burns and Ian Madin of the Oregon Department of Geology and Mineral Industries.
Of West Linn's 9,170 buildings, between 3 and 5 percent would be destroyed in a 9.0 Cascadia event, depending on whether soils are dry or saturated at the time of the event. Casualities or serious injuries are expected to be minimal, under 10.
However, a quake involving the Portland Hills fault line, which runs through West Linn, is expected to cause significantly more damage and casualties. A daytime quake is estimated to cause serious injury or deaths in as many as 50 people and as many of 24 percent of the city's buildings destroyed. Those numbers would rise even higher if soils were saturated.
While the city's new reservoir for drinking water is seismically stable its source in Oregon City is not. However, West Linn does have an emergency water source in Lake Oswego's water treatment facility in the Bolton neighborhood and nearby Abernethy Bridge was upgraded in 2010.
Recovering from a Cascadia earthquake won't be just a matter of putting out fires and stemming floods. There will be region-wide challenges to restore power, bridges and freeways, provide emergency medical care and assure food and water can be delivered. It will take months just to inspect homes and other damaged buildings to see if they're safe to occupy. Meanwhile, many will have to find other shelter, and some work places will have to be closed or relocated.
More sophisticated software, new findings
The new study, while showing more severe impacts than previous estimates, didn't bring any surprises or point to any new preparation efforts that haven't been considered before, said Dan Douthit, spokesman for the Portland Bureau of Emergency Management.
"We've already been expecting significant damages," Douthit said, "and every year that goes by, we get more and more prepared."
Emergency planners still will focus on the region's greatest vulnerabilities, including more than 1,600 unreinforced masonry buildings in the city of Portland. "We know that unreinforced masonry buildings are likely to collapse, especially during a Cascadia Subduction Zone earthquake," Douthit said. "Those pose an immediate life safety risk for people in them and people walking by during an earthquake."
But the new study, using more sophisticated Hazus software developed for the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), enabled scientists to drill down to damages at the neighborhood level as never before. The software is being constantly refined, incorporating real-world experiences from floods and earthquakes taking place around the world.
That enabled scientists to calculate the number of deaths, life-threatening injuries and hospitalizations that will occur in different neighborhood clusters in Portland and cities around the tri-county area.
Scientists now calculate there have been at least 40 large-magnitude earthquakes over the past 10,000 years along the 600-mile-long Cascadia Subduction Zone off the coasts of Oregon, Washington and Northern California. The most recent one occurred in 1700, and one study calculated there is a 15 percent to 20 percent chance that another one will occur in the next 50 years off the central and northern Oregon Coast.
The Portland Hills fault is directly beneath downtown Portland and extends into population centers of Clackamas County, so local damages could be much greater. However, there have been only two ruptures there in the last 15,000 years, according to the study.
Much of the damage from an earthquake depends on its severity and when it occurs. There will be fewer people injured if one occurs at night while people are sleeping, as wooden-frame homes are about the safest type of building construction during earthquakes. Quakes occurring during the daytime in the rainy season, when the soils are wet, will cause the greatest harm.
In the city of Portland, a major Cascadia quake could cause 675 deaths, life-threatening injuries and hospitalizations if it occurred during a late night during the summer. If the same quake occurred during the day in the rainy season, the number of serious casualties would jump to 4,549, according to the study.
Many minor casualties suffered during a quake could be addressed via simple first aid. The study points to the need for more people to get trained in first aid and how to respond to emergencies in their neighborhoods, Douthit said. Such training is provided for people volunteering with the city's Neighborhood Emergency Teams.
Those volunteers can take some of the load off hospitals, which are likely to get overwhelmed during a major quake.
As bad as conditions will be in the tri-county area under either scenario, it will be far worse on the Oregon Coast should there be a major Cascadia rupture.
"A tsunami danger from a Cascadia earthquake has the potential to kill more people than the ground shaking in Portland," Douthit said.
State geologists plan to release a second phase of their study next year, charting the potential impacts to Clark County, Washington and Columbia County, Oregon.
You count on us to stay informed and we depend on you to fund our efforts. Quality local journalism takes time and money. Please support us to protect the future of community journalism.